Limits

Why no one can guarantee a removal

Removal depends on parties no service controls. Here is why promises fail, and what a careful removal process can still do.

Standfirm

4m read

An award rosette crossed by a diagonal bar

A removal service sends requests. Other parties decide what happens to them: site operators, hosts, search engines and platforms. That is the plain reason no one can honestly promise that a piece of content will come down, or that it will stay down.

Why promises fail

Content comes back

In its Section 512 report of May 21, 2020, the US Copyright Office recorded what rightsholders told it about “the ‘whack-a-mole’ problem of infringing content reappearing after being taken down”. The Office concluded that the system is “unbalanced”.

A removal deals with one copy at one address. A re-upload is a new copy at a new address, and it needs a new request.

The law sets no deadline

Under 17 U.S.C. 512(c)(1)(C), a provider “responds expeditiously to remove, or disable access to, the material”. No number of days appears in the text.

Some sites do not answer

When a site operator stays silent, the complaint has to move to other parties. They are not all covered by the same law. Domain registrars, for example, are not named in section 512, so a complaint to a registrar rests on that registrar’s own abuse policy.

A removal can be reversed

Under 512(g)(2)(C), after a counter-notice the provider “replaces the removed material… not less than 10, nor more than 14, business days following receipt of the counter notice”, unless the person who complained files a court action first.

Search engines make their own decisions

A Bing Webmaster post from 2016 says reported URLs “are not automatically removed”. Google’s Results about you help says Google generally keeps pages from “Educational or government institutions” and “Newspapers”.

Some places are out of reach

The Telegram FAQ states: “Private groups and chats on Telegram are private amongst their participants. We do not process any requests related to them.” Public content is different. The same FAQ sends copyright complaints to dmca@telegram.org and notes that “All Telegram apps have ‘Report’ buttons”.

What a careful process can still do

None of this means removal is pointless. It means the work is a process, not a single request.

  • Follow-up. Because “expeditiously” has no date attached, an unanswered notice needs chasing.

  • Escalation. Standfirm moves a complaint up a ladder: the site owner, the hosting provider, the domain registrar, the ad networks, the upstream providers, the authorities.

  • Search delisting in parallel. Delisting does not remove a page, but it makes it harder to find. Google’s spam policies add that “a significant volume of valid copyright removal requests involving a given site” can be used “to demote other content from the site in our results”.

  • Repeat detection. Standfirm checks search engines, runs an in-house scanner across 60+ high-risk leak sites, and uses a face search whose candidate matches are reviewed by a person. No search method finds every copy.

  • Evidence. Each capture is sealed, so there is a record of what was online and when.

What the evidence record proves

Each Standfirm capture carries a SHA-256 fingerprint and an RFC 3161 timestamp from an independent authority.

Part of the record

What the standard says

What it supports

SHA-256 fingerprint

FIPS 180-4: “any change to the message will, with a very high probability, result in a different message digest.”

The capture has not been altered since it was sealed.

RFC 3161 timestamp

RFC 3161: “A time-stamping service supports assertions of proof that a datum existed before a particular time.”

The capture existed before the stamped time.

Neither one proves who posted the material or whether it is unlawful. Together they give you a record that someone else can check later.

What this means for you

Be careful with any service that promises removal, a fixed date or permanence. Ask what happens when a site does not answer, how follow-up works and what record you receive.

Standfirm does not promise removal, and it does not promise that removed material stays gone.

Sources

This guide is general information, not legal advice.

More guides

Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.