Process

What happens after a takedown notice is sent

What US law asks of a provider after a DMCA notice, how counter-notices work, and what escalation means when a site stays silent.

Standfirm

4m read

An hourglass on a short flight of steps with an envelope

Sending a takedown notice starts a process. It does not finish one. What happens next depends on who received the notice and how they respond. This guide walks through the stages and is plain about where things can stall.

The provider is expected to act "expeditiously"

The timing rule is in 17 U.S.C. 512(c)(1)(C). After a valid notice, the provider "responds expeditiously to remove, or disable access to, the material".

That is the whole rule. No number of days appears in the text, so nobody can read a removal date out of the statute.

European Union law uses similar language. Article 16 of the Digital Services Act says hosting providers "shall put mechanisms in place to allow any individual or entity to notify them" of illegal content, and that decisions are made "in a timely, diligent, non-arbitrary and objective manner". That wording also sets a standard, not a number of days.

The other side can answer with a counter-notice

Section 512 also provides for a counter-notice. Under 512(g)(2)(C), the provider "replaces the removed material... not less than 10, nor more than 14, business days following receipt of the counter notice", unless the person who complained files a court action first.

Two things follow:

  • A removal can be reversed. Material taken down under a notice can go back up through this route.

  • The 10 to 14 business day figure is often read as a takedown deadline. It is not one. It applies only to putting material back after a counter-notice.

The stages at a glance

Stage

What the source says

What it means for you

Notice received

The provider "responds expeditiously"

No fixed date. Plan to follow up.

Counter-notice

Material is replaced in "not less than 10, nor more than 14, business days" unless a court action is filed first

A removal can be undone.

False statements

512(f): a person who "knowingly materially misrepresents" is liable for damages, costs and attorneys' fees

Applies to a false notice and to a false claim that material was removed by mistake.

No response from the site

The notice rule gives no number of days

Follow up, then escalate to other parties, each under its own rules.

When a site ignores the notice

Some site operators do not respond. Escalation means taking the complaint to the other parties that keep the site online. Standfirm works up a ladder in this order.

  • The hosting provider. Section 512 defines a service provider broadly, as "a provider of online services or network access, or the operator of facilities therefor". The host is the next step after the site owner.

  • The domain registrar. Section 512 has four headings: "Transitory Digital Network Communications", "System Caching", "Information Residing on Systems or Networks At Direction of Users" and "Information Location Tools". Registrars are not named in it. A complaint to a registrar rests on that registrar's own abuse policy, not on the DMCA.

  • Ad networks and upstream providers. Each sets its own rules for complaints. This guide makes no claim about how any one of them responds.

  • The authorities. The last step, for cases that call for it.

Search delisting runs in parallel. Standfirm files with Google, Bing and Yandex, under each engine's own process, while removal at the source continues, because removing a search result and removing a page are separate jobs.

Honest limits

  • No deadline. "Expeditiously" is the only timing word in the notice rule.

  • Reversal. A counter-notice can bring material back.

  • Private policies. A registrar escalation depends on the registrar's own policy.

  • Reappearance. In its Section 512 report of May 21, 2020, the US Copyright Office recorded rightsholders describing "the 'whack-a-mole' problem of infringing content reappearing after being taken down".

No one can promise that a notice will lead to removal. What a careful process can do is follow up, escalate in order and keep a dated record of each step. Standfirm's process has four steps for that reason: detect, escalate, document, hand off.

Sources

This guide is general information, not legal advice.

Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.